Agenda item

The Director of Economic Growth and Neighbourhood Services will report that, Inspectors, appointed by the Secretary of State for the Environment, have:-

Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington DL2 1HS

Appeal A

Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s split decision insofar as it relates to the road condition survey and the road safety audit in relation to The Greenway and Grendon Gardens submitted pursuant to conditions 10 and 11 attached to planning permission reference 15/00976/OUT granted on 1 July 2016, in accordance with application 18/00959/CON dated 15 October 2018 and the details submitted with it are approved at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington  (18/00959/CON) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached).

Dismissed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s split decision insofar as it relates to Condition 18 (bat risk assessment) attached to planning permission reference 15/00976/OUT granted 1 July 2016 in accordance with application 18/00959/CON dated 15 October 2018 and the details submitted with it are refused at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington. (18/00922/CON) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached)

Appeal B

Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s decision to refuse consent for approval of details reserved by Condition 2 (Phasing of Development and the Route of Construction Details) attached to attached to planning permission 17/01151/RM1 dated 14 March 2018 (Reserved matters relating to details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale, for residential development of 198 no. dwellings pursuant to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 01 July 2016 (Amended access proposed, plans received 11 January 2018)) and Approval of details reserved by Condition 14 (Details of the Implementation, Maintenance And Management of the Sustainable Drainage Scheme) attached to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 1 July 2016 (Outline planning permission for residential development up to 200 dwellings including highway improvements, public open space at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington (18/00922/CON) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached)

Appeal C

Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s decision to refuse consent for approval of details reserved by Condition 3 (Construction Management Plan) attached to attached to planning permission 17/01151/RM1 dated 14 March 2018 (Reserved matters relating to details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale, for residential development of 198 no. dwellings pursuant to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 01 July 2016 (Amended access proposed, plans received 11 January 2018)) and Condition 9 (Construction Management Plan) attached to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington (18/00921/CON) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached)

Award of costs against the Council in respect of the three appeals at High Stell Middleton St George, Darlington DL2 1HS.  (Copy of Inspector’s costs decision attached). 

Gladman Developments Ltd Appeal

The appeal by Gladman Developments Ltd for Land off Neasham Road, Middleton St George, Darlington has been withdrawn.

Partial award of costs against the appellant in respect of the withdrawn application at Land off Neasham Road, Middleton St George, Darlington (Copy of Inspector’s costs decision attached).

Dismissed the appeal by Dr I Rehman against this Authority’s decision to refuse permission for the erection of a detached oak framed dwelling at Land Adjacent to Rowan house, Middleton Road, Sadberge, Darlington (18/00807/FUL) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached)

RECOMMENDED – That the report be received.

The Director of Economic Growth and Neighbourhood Services reported that the Inspectors appointed by the Secretary of State for the Environment had:

(a)  Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s split decision insofar as it relates to the road condition survey and the road safety audit in relation to The Greenway and Grendon Gardens submitted pursuant to conditions 10 and 11 attached to planning permission reference 15/00976/OUT granted on 1 July 2016, in accordance with application 18/00959/CON dated 15 October 2018 and the details submitted with it are approved at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington  (18/00959/CON).

(b)  Dismissed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s split decision insofar as it relates to Condition 18 (bat risk assessment) attached to planning permission reference 15/00976/OUT granted 1 July 2016 in accordance with application 18/00959/CON dated 15 October 2018 and the details submitted with it are refused at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington. (18/00922/CON).

(c)  Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s decision to refuse consent for approval of details reserved by Condition 2 (Phasing of Development and the Route of Construction Details) attached to attached to planning permission 17/01151/RM1 dated 14 March 2018 (Reserved matters relating to details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale, for residential development of 198 no. dwellings pursuant to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 01 July 2016 (Amended access proposed, plans received 11 January 2018)) and Approval of details reserved by Condition 14 (Details of the Implementation, Maintenance And Management of the Sustainable Drainage Scheme) attached to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 1 July 2016 (Outline planning permission for residential development up to 200 dwellings including highway improvements, public open space at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington (18/00922/CON).

(d)  Allowed the appeal by Mr Craig Peterson (Homes by Carlton (MSTG1) Limited) against this Authority’s decision to refuse consent for approval of details reserved by Condition 3 (Construction Management Plan) attached to attached to planning permission 17/01151/RM1 dated 14 March 2018 (Reserved matters relating to details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale, for residential development of 198 no. dwellings pursuant to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT dated 01 July 2016 (Amended access proposed, plans received 11 January 2018)) and Condition 9 (Construction Management Plan) attached to outline planning permission 15/00976/OUT at Land at Rear of High Stell, Middleton St George, Darlington (18/00921/CON) (Copy of Inspector’s decision letter attached)

Award of costs against the Council in respect of the three appeals at High Stell Middleton St George, Darlington DL2 1HS.  (Copy of Inspector’s costs decision attached).

(e)  The appeal by Gladman Developments Ltd for Land off Neasham Road, Middleton St George, Darlington has been withdrawn.

Partial award of costs against the appellant in respect of the withdrawn application at Land off Neasham Road, Middleton St George, Darlington.

(f)   Dismissed the appeal by Dr I Rehman against this Authority’s decision to refuse permission for the erection of a detached oak framed dwelling at Land Adjacent to Rowan house, Middleton Road, Sadberge, Darlington (18/00807/FUL).

RESOLVED – That the report be received.